THE NEWS International, 19th August 2000 I am glad that Professor Asghar Qadir at last has come out in public with his point of view vis-a-vis the controversial Impact Factor (The News, August 7, 2000 ). Soon after my first article on the Impact Factor, Rating Pakistani Scientists , was published (The News, October 28, 1999), I wrote an open letter to Professor Asghar Qadir asking him to give his professional opinion. There was no response from him until my second article, The Impact Factor and Mathematicians (The News, July 19, 2000 ). It is important that mathematicians within and outside Pakistan know the stand he has taken. My first article highlighted a number of crucial defects in the criterion. Professor Qadir's admittance that the criterion of Impact Factor has many flaws makes my case for rejection of the criterion more justifiable. I need not repeat myself here in highlighting the defects, deficiencies, and deceptions of the criterion. However, I w...